The New York Times, renowned for its culinary coverage, frequently features dishes that highlight the versatility and deliciousness of fish. While a definitive list of every fish ever featured in a NYT tartare recipe is impossible to compile, we can explore the most common and celebrated varieties frequently prepared in this delicate, flavorful style. This exploration will delve into why these specific fish work so well, highlighting their textural and flavor profiles ideal for a tartare preparation.
The Classics: Tuna and Salmon
Unsurprisingly, tuna and salmon are consistently featured in NYT-style recipes for fish tartare. Their popularity stems from several factors:
-
Rich Flavor Profiles: Both tuna and salmon offer robust, distinct flavors that stand up well to the other components of a tartare—acidic elements like lemon juice, pungent herbs like chives or dill, and creamy additions like avocado or mayonnaise.
-
Textural Versatility: When properly handled, both tuna and salmon possess a firm yet tender texture that holds its shape beautifully in a tartare. This is crucial for achieving the desired mouthfeel. The quality of the fish is paramount here; opting for sustainably sourced, high-quality options is vital.
-
Accessibility: Tuna and salmon are widely available in most supermarkets and fishmongers, making them convenient choices for both home cooks and professional chefs.
Beyond the Basics: Expanding Your Tartare Horizons
While tuna and salmon dominate, the NYT and other high-end culinary sources showcase a more diverse range of fish suitable for tartare.
1. Yellowtail (Hamachi):
This prized fish offers a subtly sweet and buttery flavor that contrasts beautifully with the acidity often found in tartare preparations. Its delicate texture makes it a luxurious choice.
2. Scallops:
While technically a mollusk, scallops are often included in the broader conversation around fish tartare. Their firm, slightly sweet flesh provides a delightful textural contrast and complements the other ingredients brilliantly. Look for dry-packed or seared scallops for the best results.
3. Swordfish:
A firmer fish than tuna, swordfish offers a robust, meaty flavor that holds up well to stronger seasonings and bold flavor combinations. It's a great option for those who prefer a heartier tartare experience.
4. White Fish Options:
Many firm white fish, such as cod, halibut, and sea bass, can be successfully prepared as tartare, although they may require more careful attention to seasoning and the addition of flavorful components to enhance their relatively mild flavor. Their delicate texture, however, works well in a tartare context.
Key Considerations for Successful Fish Tartare
Regardless of the type of fish you choose, remember these essential points for a successful tartare:
-
Freshness is Paramount: Use only the freshest, highest-quality fish available. The flavor and texture of the final dish rely heavily on the starting ingredients.
-
Proper Handling: Handle the fish carefully to avoid contamination and ensure its texture remains intact. Follow safe food handling guidelines meticulously.
-
Balanced Flavors: The success of any tartare hinges on a balance of flavors—acidic, savory, and perhaps a touch of sweetness. Experiment with different herbs, spices, and citrus fruits to achieve your ideal combination.
-
Texture is Key: Achieve the right balance of texture through careful dicing of the fish and thoughtful inclusion of other ingredients that complement, rather than overwhelm, the star of the show.
By understanding the nuances of different fish and applying these key considerations, you can create a memorable and delicious fish tartare worthy of even the most discerning New York Times food critic. Remember to always prioritize quality ingredients and safe food handling practices.
